S’More Festive Fashioned

Jessica Sturdy shares a cocktail recipe that's great for the holidays. A Festive Old Fashioned made with Toasted Marshmallows and Chocolate Bitters.

‘Tis the season to be festive! 🎄 With the holiday season in full swing and friends and family get-togethers right around the corner, I’m so excited to share a recipe for a S’mores Festive Fashionedwith Old Forester, as well as a few tidbits I learned while visiting their Louisville distillery a few weeks ago.

This post was created in partnership with Old Forester and intended for audiences 21+. Thank you for supporting the brands and collaborations that make Bows & Sequins possible!

Jessica Sturdy shares a cocktail recipe that's great for the holidays. A Smore's Old Fashioned made with Toasted Marshmallows and Chocolate Bitters.

Let’s first start with a fun cocktail, shall we?! This festive spin on a classic cocktail is sure to be a hit this time of year… I mean, who doesn’t love a toasted marshmallow?! 

Here’s what you’ll need…

  • 2oz Old Forester 1910 Old Fine Whiskey
  • 0.5oz Vanilla Simple Syrup
  • 2 Dashes Angostura Bitters
  • 2 Dashes Chocolate Bitters
  • Toasted Marshmallow

Jessica Sturdy shares a cocktail recipe that's great for the holidays. A Smore's Old Fashioned made with Old Forester 1910, Vanilla Simple Syrup, Chocolate Bitters, Angostura Bitters, and Toasted Marshmallow.

Chocolate bitters were easy to find at my local liquor store, and feel free to get creative and use Angostura Orange Bitters for a taste that’s closer to a classic Old Fashioned. If you can’t find Vanilla Simple Syrup (or, you know, your delivery gets delayed 🙃), it’s actually so easy to make your own on the stovetop. There are a ton of recipes online, but you’ll basically just need sugar, water, and vanilla extract. For the marshmallows, I toasted mine on my gas stovetop, but I’m sure a kitchen torch would work just as well — just be careful! I’d recommend toasting more than you need to serve alongside your cocktails.

Putting this S’mores Festive Fashioned together couldn’t be easier…

  1. Stir all ingredients in a mixing glass with ice.
  2. Strain into a double old fashioned glass with fresh ice.
  3. Garnish with a toasted marshmallow and serve!

Jessica Sturdy shares a cocktail recipe that's great for the holidays. A Smore's Old Fashioned made with Toasted Marshmallows and Chocolate Bitters.

If you caught my Perfect Old Fashioned recipe on Instagram a few weeks ago, you might notice that this recipe calls for a different bottle of Old Forester bourbon. A few weeks ago, I got the opportunity to visit the Old Forester distillery on Whiskey Row in downtown Louisville and learned so much about the brand’s history and their different expressions of bourbon. I also got to do a tasting with their Master Taster, Jackie Zykan! (I’ll save this conversation for a different day, but I thought it was so cool that all of the Old Forester employees I met on this trip were female… From the Master Taster to the Digital Marketing Manager to the tour lead and beyond! #WhoRunTheWorld)

Jessica Sturdy at the Old Forester Distillery in Louisville Kentucky

The tour was so informative, interesting, and interactive! From getting up close and personal with the fermentation tanks to seeing how Old Forester chars all of their own barrels, there wasn’t a dull moment. And #NerdAlert, but I loved learning about the history of the brand along the way! Did you know that Old Forester was the first bottled bourbon?! Old Forester also survived prohibition as the only bourbon continually sold by the same family-controlled company before, during, and after the prohibition.

Old Forester Tasting in Louisville

After our tour, we got to taste! We did a bourbon tasting that was like going down Old Forester memory lane — 1870 Original Batch, 1897 Bottled in Bond, 1910 Old Fine Whisky, and 1920 Prohibition Style. We also enjoyed Modjeskas alongside, which couldn’t have been a better compliment. These handmade marshmallows, wrapped in caramel, hand-dipped in bourbon dark chocolate then sprinkled with smoked sea salt are worth the trip to Louisville in and of themselves, but thankfully you can order them online!

Bourbon and Chocolate Pairing - Old Forester Modjeskas

As I mentioned earlier, the S’mores Festive Fashioned calls for 1910 Old Fine Whisky. On October 22, 1910, a fire on the bottling line halted production of Old Forester. There was mature whisky that was ready to be bottled, that was instead stored in a secondary barrel. What emerged was Old Fine Whisky. Today’s bottles of 1910 mimic this historic bottling… This expression Old Forester has undergone a second barreling, which gives it a smoother, sweeter flavor with more notes of charred oak. Which goes oh-so-well with a freshly toasted marshmallow in the S’mores Festive Fashioned!

Jessica Sturdy shares a cocktail recipe that's great for the holidays. A Smore's Old Fashioned made with Toasted Marshmallows and Chocolate Bitters.

What are the holidays without a little gift?! Don’t forget to use code OLDFOJS to get $10 towards your purchase of Old Forester on Drizly. Cheers!

Code only valid on Drizly. Must be 21+. Cannot be combined with any other offer. Code valid when you purchase Old Forester (375ml +). Minimum purchase $19.00.  Valid in CO, IL, DC, and FL. Rebate will automatically be applied towards order total or shipping or delivery fees. Includes orders of non-alcoholic items.Void where prohibited. Drizly Terms & Conditions apply.

Leave a Comment